This is a purely educational website. Nothing here is legal advice or creates or implies an attorney-client relationship. If you have a specific legal issue, PLEASE talk to a lawyer who practices where you live—laws vary from place to place, and how they're applied varies from courthouse to courthouse. Your local county bar association can probably refer someone who handles matters like yours.
By using this site, you agree that you are awesome. Use of this site also constitutes acceptance of its
Terms of Service and Privacy Policies, which are known to medical science as a cure for insomnia.
It's best to keep all discussions in the comments. But if you really need to reach Nathan privately, go ahead and email him at n.e.burney@gmail.com. He won't mind.
THE ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO LAW and the PEEKING JUSTICE logo are pretty damn cool trademarks and should probably be registered one of these days.
© Nathaniel Burney. All rights reserved, though they really open up once you get to know them.
Awesome comic, keep it up!.
https://patch.com/maryland/odenton/toddler-left-hot-vehicle-dies-naval-air-station#.VAjmDmRdXaY
tl:dr: dad forgets child in car seat, child dies. Involuntary manslaughter charge (but not convicted yet).
This has always bothered me. What purpose does this punishment serve (assuming he receive that conviction)? You can’t rehabilitate his forgetfulness. You can’t deter others from doing something they don’t intent to. Perhaps to remove a danger from society (a person who forgets things..)? He had no intention of doing what he did.
I don’t quite see how this is all that different from your artichoke allergic baby example?
It’s the difference between “you should have been more careful, but you weren’t,” which is punishable, and “you can’t be expected to have known that,” which is not punishable.
Isn’t having your baby die a punishment?
(Yes I do see the potential loophole then if somebody does want to kill their child)
Criminal punishment is something the State does to you. Not something you do to yourself. See REGRET.
(That’s not to say “he’s suffered enough” isn’t a valid argument to make at sentencing, however.)
As an exercise, pretend he’s just been found guilty of criminally negligent homicide in a state with a maximum sentence of 5 years, and no minimum. Considering the various purposes of punishment, and any facts you think are relevant, come up with sentencing arguments as the prosecutor and then as the defense attorney.