Be sure to share your comments in the Class Participation section below -- that's the best part! Also, you can use the arrows on your keyboard to flip through pages quickly.
Join the conversation!
There are now 16 comments on pg 18. Star Chamber: Inquisitorial, Not Adversarial.
What are your thoughts?
    • Here’s a comparison of the famous ceiling as it looked in back in the day, and how it looked in the mid-1800s (a couple hundred years after the Court of Star Chamber itself had ceased to exist):
      Star Chamber Ceilings

  1. Greg says

    I think you meant “seen” instead of “seem” there at the lower left.

  2. austin says

    “inquisitorial system” i didnt expect that.

    • It’s a loaded word, but the root is the same as that of “inquiry” – the goal is to try to figure out what happened!

      One corollary here is that adversarial systems like ours don’t always care what actually happened. It’s interesting that under our system, a criminal could be correctly found guilty of a crime, even if the prosecution’s argument for HOW it happened turns out to be incorrect.

      • Yes, but that can happen under an inquisitorial system as well. Even the most thorough inquest could get a correct conclusion while getting any number of the particulars wrong.

  3. Peter Farland says

    Lol, wrong inquisition. Though the Torquemada outfit doesn’t help with that. Really the Star Chamber is one of those “It sounded good at the time” and “Best intentions” ideas rolled up into one. It was meant to be an appeals court, which I believe (other than by going to the King himself) was an entirely new concept. It was also a way to go after those considered untouchable by the regular courts (something we could use today, I’m looking at you “Dream Team” defense lawyers). It also had the ability to convict those that while following the letter of the law, broke the spirit of it into little chunks. All things that sound like good ideas. Until people got involved in it.

  4. Computant says

    I love how the king stops the guy with a hand on his midriff, but he holds back the woman with a hand on her chest-it’s good to be the king!

  5. James says

    Gorgeous picture of Salisbury Cathedral. It’s really difficult to get the proportions just right, but you’ve managed it.

    You could have mentioned it has the best-preserved copy of Magna Carta inside, though — and that the building is five years younger than the document!

Class Participation

Advertisements: